• 中国科学学与科技政策研究会
  • 中国科学院科技战略咨询研究院
  • 清华大学科学技术与社会研究中心
ISSN 1003-2053 CN 11-1805/G3

科学学研究 ›› 2026, Vol. 44 ›› Issue (9): 1865-1879.

• 理论与方法 • 上一篇    下一篇

新能源汽车产业“内卷”的破局之道——基于柔性演化与优势涌现的双重视角

徐彦申(), 范旭   

  1. 华南理工大学公共管理学院, 广东广州 510641
  • 收稿日期:2025-06-20 修回日期:2025-11-13 出版日期:2026-09-15 发布日期:2026-09-15
  • 作者简介:徐彦申(1993-),女,博士研究生,E-mail:202110187804@mail.scut.edu.cn。
    范旭(1962-),男,教授。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社会科学基金重点项目(24AKS019);广州市哲学社会科学规划项目(2023GZYB12)

Breaking the "involution" in the new energy vehicle industry——A dual perspective of flexible evolution and advantage emergence

XU Yan-shen(), FAN Xu   

  1. School of Public Administration, South China University of Technology, Guangzhou 510641, China
  • Received:2025-06-20 Revised:2025-11-13 Online:2026-09-15 Published:2026-09-15

摘要:

在新能源汽车产业的“内卷式”竞争背景下,企业如何突破内卷困局、构建持续性的竞争优势成为亟待探讨的重要议题。本研究采用双案例对比研究法,以“小鹏”和“威马”为研究对象,构建“内卷环境—柔性建构—优势涌现”的分析框架,探析企业如何在内卷情境中通过柔性机制实现竞争优势的连续性涌现。研究发现:(1)新能源汽车产业的内卷环境分别呈现出“不确定性”“结构化”和“极化”的阶段特征;(2)在内卷压力下,柔性机制经历了“基础柔性—局部柔性—全域柔性”的演化过程;(3)企业竞争优势在柔性机制的推动下,呈现出“敏捷型试错优势—路径型协作优势—系统型协同优势”的连续性涌现路径。本研究拓展了柔性理论在高频动态环境下的适用边界,并进一步建构了本土内卷语境下企业突围的过程模型,为企业应对产业内卷提供了理论依据和实践参考。

关键词: 组织柔性, 优势涌现, 新能源汽车, 内卷式竞争

Abstract:

In recent years, "involutionary competition" has emerged as a salient and defining feature of China's new energy vehicle (NEV) industry. Between 2018 and 2024, approximately 400 NEV firms exited the market amid intensified price wars, excessive capacity expansion, and escalating cost pressures. While involutionary competition may initially accelerate market selection and resource reallocation, prolonged competition driven by aggressive price-cutting and extreme cost compression has increasingly undermined technological innovation, distorted industrial ecosystems, and constrained high-quality development. Against this backdrop, a critical question arises: how can firms break through involutionary traps and construct sustainable competitive advantages under conditions of persistent and system-wide competitive pressure?

Existing studies on involution primarily adopt a macro-institutional perspective, emphasizing policy regulation, industrial governance, and the restoration of market order. These studies have contributed valuable insights into the structural and institutional origins of involutionary competition, particularly the role of government intervention in shaping industry dynamics. However, they provide limited explanations of how firms, at the organizational level, respond to and survive under sustained involutionary pressure. This limitation is especially evident in the NEV industry, where rapid technological iteration, high capital intensity, and converging technological trajectories expose firms to continuous environmental shocks. As a result, the micro-level mechanisms through which firms adapt to involution and achieve strategic breakthroughs remain theoretically underexplored.

To address this gap, this study introduces an organizational flexibility perspective and develops a process-oriented analytical framework to explain how firms achieve the continuous emergence of competitive advantages in involutionary environments. Drawing on theories of organizational flexibility and emergence, this research conceptualizes competitive advantage not as a deliberately designed or static outcome, but as an evolutionary process shaped by ongoing interactions between firms and their environments. Organizational flexibility is understood as a firm's capacity to adjust resource configurations, strategic orientations, and organizational arrangements in response to environmental disturbances. Extending prior static interpretations, this study emphasizes the dynamic evolution of flexibility itself under sustained competitive pressure.

Methodologically, this research adopts a comparative case study design, examining XPeng Motors and WM Motor-two Chinese NEV manufacturers that were exposed to similar external conditions but experienced divergent outcomes. By systematically comparing a "breakthrough" firm with an "exited" firm, this study constructs an analytical framework of "involutionary environment-flexible construction-advantage emergence" to reveal how different flexibility trajectories shape organizational evolution. The comparative approach enables the identification of key mechanisms through which flexibility influences firm survival and strategic outcomes under involutionary competition.

The findings reveal three main insights. First, the involutionary environment of the NEV industry evolves through three distinct stages: uncertainty, structural convergence, and polarization. Each stage imposes different adaptive pressures on firms. Second, under escalating involutionary pressure, organizational flexibility evolves from foundational flexibility to partial flexibility and ultimately to global flexibility. Foundational flexibility enables low-cost experimentation and rapid adjustment in uncertain environments; partial flexibility supports coordinated responses at critical organizational nodes; and global flexibility integrates resources, structures, and strategies into a system-wide adaptive capability. Third, driven by the evolution of flexibility, firms' competitive advantages emerge along a continuous path, progressing from agile trial-and-error advantages to path-based collaboration advantages and finally to system-level synergy advantages.

This study makes three primary theoretical contributions. First, it develops a process model that explains firm breakout mechanisms within China's involutionary context, thereby localizing organizational theory to a distinctive competitive environment. Second, it extends organizational flexibility theory by demonstrating how flexibility dynamically evolves under high-frequency environmental disturbances. Third, it reconceptualizes competitive advantage as a multi-stage emergent process driven by flexible evolution rather than static resource endowments.

Key words: organizational flexibility, advantage emergence, new energy vehicles, involutionary competition

中图分类号: